Lakeway is one of the cheaper places in Texas to insure a car, and the two ZIP codes that make up the city, 78734 and 78738, both land around $1,600 a year for full coverage. That's about 42% under the statewide full-coverage average of $2,751.

The discount traces back to two things that usually move in opposite directions: a wealthy resident base and an unusually low crime rate. Lakeway has both.

Lakeway Auto Insurance at a Glance

  • Typical annual premium: ~$1,600/yr (full coverage, 78734/78738)
  • Texas minimum-coverage average: $786/yr
  • Texas full-coverage average: $2,751/yr
  • State minimum required: 30/60/25 liability
  • Fault system: At-fault (tort) — Texas standard
  • Crime grade: A+, violent crime ~78/100,000 vs. national ~359/100,000

A Median Income Over Twice the State Figure

Lakeway's median household income sits above $160,000 a year, more than double the statewide figure near $76,000. That kind of income shows up in the driveways — newer trucks, SUVs, and the occasional lake-house second vehicle — all of which cost more to repair or replace after a crash.

Higher-income drivers also tend to file fewer claims and qualify for better pricing tiers, and in Lakeway's case that discount outweighs the cost of insuring pricier vehicles. The net result is a rate that runs well under the state average rather than at it.

An A+ Crime Grade That Lowers Comprehensive Claims

Lakeway's violent crime rate works out to roughly 78 incidents per 100,000 residents, against a national average near 359 — a gap that puts the city's overall crime rate somewhere between 38% and 53% below the national figure depending on the dataset. Either way, it's an A+ grade.

Comprehensive coverage, the part of a policy that pays for theft and vandalism, prices directly off numbers like these. Fewer break-ins and stolen vehicles mean fewer comprehensive payouts, and that history is exactly what lets a city price below the state average.

Where the Discount Runs Out: Hill Country Roads

The low crime rate doesn't say much about the roads. RR 620 and Flint Rock Road cut through genuine Hill Country terrain — blind curves, narrow shoulders, and elevation changes that a flat Texas grid street never has to account for.

  • Seasonal lake traffic: Spring and summer weekends bring boat trailers and out-of-town visitors to Lake Travis, adding drivers unfamiliar with the curves to the same two-lane roads locals use daily.
  • Limited through-routes: Lakeway Boulevard and Hwy 71 carry most of the traffic in and out of town, so a single stall or fender-bender backs up the whole corridor.
  • Micro-ZIP pricing: Carriers that break rates down below the ZIP level do pick up slightly more frequent low-speed collisions along the lake-access corridors than in the subdivisions set back from the water.

Hail Season Reaches the Lake Too

Central Texas hail doesn't skip waterfront towns. A spring storm that dents roofs around Lake Travis does the same to any car parked outside, and comprehensive coverage is the only part of a policy that pays for that kind of damage.

Given how far Lakeway's rate already sits below the state average, trimming comprehensive to save a few more dollars a month is a bad trade the first time a hailstorm rolls through the Highland Lakes.

Keeping Lakeway's Rate Advantage

  • Compare quotes from at least three carriers — insurers weight the income and crime data differently, and the spread can be wider than the city average suggests.
  • Ask about garage-parking or low-mileage discounts if your vehicle isn't driven on RR 620 or Flint Rock Road daily.
  • Keep comprehensive coverage active through hail season instead of trimming it to shave a few dollars off the premium.

Our guide to comparing quotes covers what to check beyond the sticker price, and the uninsured motorist coverage guide explains why Texas insurers can't drop that protection without your signature.

Texas requires 30/60/25 liability coverage statewide, and about one in seven Texas drivers carries no insurance at all. Lakeway's low crime rate and high incomes help keep comprehensive claims down, but neither does anything to protect against an uninsured driver on RR 620 — that coverage is worth keeping regardless of how safe or wealthy the city is.