Ask someone which town up north has the most people, and almost everyone says Traverse City. They're wrong. Garfield Charter Township, the ring of suburbs and strip malls wrapped around the city's south and west side, has more year-round residents than Traverse City itself.
That gap in name recognition doesn't carry over to car insurance in Garfield Township, though. Coverage requirements, no-fault rules, and PIP options come from Lansing and apply identically whether your address says Garfield Township or Traverse City on the mailing label.
Garfield Township Car Insurance at a Glance
- Population: roughly 19,700, largest municipality in Northern Lower Michigan
- Government: charter township since 1977, Grand Traverse County
- Location: wraps Traverse City on the south and west; shares its 4968x ZIP codes
- Main corridor: US-31 and M-37 run concurrently, the area's busiest commercial strip
- Default liability: $250,000/$500,000 bodily injury (opt-down available)
- PIP: driver-selected tier, chosen at renewal
- PPI: mandatory, $1 million
- ZIP code pricing: banned statewide since 2019 (Public Act 21)
The Bigger Town Nobody Names
Garfield Township counted 19,499 residents at the 2020 census, up from 16,256 in 2010 and 13,840 in 2000 — a steadier climb than most Michigan townships have managed this century. Traverse City, by contrast, holds around 15,900. Put the two side by side and the township most people treat as Traverse City's backyard is actually the bigger population center.
The confusion makes sense. Garfield Township has no downtown of its own to point to — no Front Street, no bay-front park — just the commercial sprawl along US-31 that most visitors assume is still "Traverse City" because that's the name on the exit sign.
One Set of Rules, Two Governments
None of that population math changes a single line of your car insurance policy. Michigan is a no-fault state, and every driver here — Garfield Township, Traverse City, or anywhere else in the state — carries the same default $250,000 per person / $500,000 per accident bodily injury liability floor, with a signed waiver available to drop to $50,000/$100,000.
On top of that, Personal Injury Protection is mandatory at a tier you select yourself at renewal, and Property Protection Insurance is required at $1 million to cover damage your vehicle causes to things that aren't other cars — fences, utility poles, storefronts along that same US-31 strip.
Why the US-31 Corridor Matters to a Quote
US-31 and M-37 run concurrently through the full length of Garfield Township, and the stretch is dense enough with retail, restaurants, and turning traffic that it's the most commercialized road in the Grand Traverse area. M-72 cuts through the township's north end heading toward Leelanau County, adding a second steady traffic flow.
Insurers don't price by township name, but they do group addresses into rating territories built partly around exactly this kind of traffic density — more turning movements and retail driveways generally mean more fender-bender claims than a quiet residential loop sees.
Silver Lake, the Boardman River, and Two High Schools
Away from the commercial strip, Garfield Township is mostly residential: Traverse City West Senior High and Traverse City West Middle School sit inside township limits near Silver Lake Elementary, and the Boardman River runs north through the township's east side on its way to Grand Traverse Bay. Silver Lake itself sits in the southwest corner, shared with neighboring Blair Township.
Liability limits don't change near water or school zones, but comprehensive coverage — the part of a full-coverage policy that pays out for storm and flood damage to your own car — is worth confirming if you park close to Silver Lake or the river corridor. For a full breakdown of what comprehensive adds over state-minimum liability, see our minimum vs. full coverage guide.
Quoting in Garfield Township
The short version: your state minimums are fixed no matter which side of the Garfield Township–Traverse City line your address falls on, your ZIP code legally can't set your price on its own, and the population numbers that make Garfield the bigger town have nothing to do with what you'll pay. Run a few quotes, compare them against the statewide averages, and let the actual numbers — not the name on the exit sign — decide where you buy coverage.
